Pink Pony

Reviews about Pink Pony

• 5 / 5

  By michelle christ
  Great food, friendly service and fun atmosphere. Our family had a great time at the Pink Pony. The Whitefish Fingers, French Dip, and Pony burger, were outstanding! The homemade chips are a nice touch but too large of a portion. Good drinks too! Our server was attentive and helpful. Can't say enough good things. You shouldn't miss this place when visiting the island.
  April 09, 2017
• 4 / 5

  By Linh Nguyen
  This restaurant was the best restaurant we went on the island. It's a bit pricey bit portions are good and food is delicious.
  
  Their white fish dip was abit too salty but it was still good.
  I had a white fish dinner, I enjoyed it alot.
  My husband had a steak and it was tender and delicious.
  
  The rum runner was similar to a magarita .not what I was expecting.
  
  If I come back to the island, I would definitely come back.
  December 26, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Katie D.
  We have tried a number of restaurants on the island and the Pink Pony has the BEST fried whitefish. It was fresh, hot in temperature (ie, had not been sitting in a hotbox), the beer batter was so good. Wonderful combination for fried whitefish, there wasn't a hint of fishy taste to it.
  Also tried the whitefish tacos, they were good but the slaw on the tacos was lacking flavor. If you want whitefish for dinner, totally go with the Fried whitefish (note: I can't attest to how the fries (chips) were since we subbed them for a side salad).
  
  July 24, 2016